Honest ECommerce | Ecommerce Profit by Channel and SKU: Parag Mamnani of Webgility
Parag Mamnani is the CEO of Webgility, the ecommerce accounting automation platform serving 5,000+ brands. He has spent 25 years in ecommerce.
He started his career at Amazon, where he saw marketplace sales data fail to match sellers’ accounting records, and he founded Webgility 19 years ago to fix that.
Today he is taking Webgility agentic, helping sellers close their books faster and see their real profit.
In This Conversation We Discuss:
- [00:00] Intro
- [01:12] From the dot-com bust to ecommerce
- [02:52] How Webgility has evolved over 20 years
- [05:04] Why bank balances don’t match QuickBooks
- [06:16] Why founders treat accounting as an afterthought
- [08:24] When top-line thinking stops working
- [10:08] Amazon’s multichannel feature and double counting
- [12:07] What sellers miss when calculating profit
- [12:41] Net deposits vs. true revenue
- [14:50] SKU-level margins and unit economics
- [16:05] Why scaling past $10M becomes pure math
- [16:59] Inventory turns and data confidence
- [18:52] Amazon’s negative-margin playbook
- [19:20] Why AI makes unit economics more essential
- [20:21] How Webgility uses AI internally
- [21:30] Why 95% accurate books aren’t good enough
- [22:15] Adding human accountability to agentic AI
- [24:11] Where to learn more about Webgility
- [25:00] Final thoughts
Resources:
- Subscribe to Honest Ecommerce on Youtube
- Real-time Ecommerce Accounting and Inventory Automation webgility.com
- Follow Parag Mamnani linkedin.com/in/paragmamnani
If you’re enjoying the show, we’d love it if you left Honest Ecommerce a review on Apple Podcasts. It makes a huge impact on the success of the podcast, and we love reading every one of your reviews!
speaker-1: Does sound scammy.
speaker-0: it’s it’s really all about do you understand the mechanics of how you’re making money?
speaker-1: Honest ECOmerce is a weekly podcast where we interview direct-to-consumer brand founders and leaders to find out what it takes to start, grow, and scale an online business today. Hey everybody, welcome back to another episode of Honest ECommerce. Today we’re welcoming the show Perog Mamanani. He is joining us as the CEO of Web Agility. He has spent 25 years in the e-comm industry and he has built in Accounting automation platforms sellers have trusted for over nineteen of those years. And now, obviously, with the rise of AI, he’s taking it agentic. Purog, welcome to the show.
speaker-0: Awesome. Thanks for having me, Chase. Great to be here.
speaker-1: I’m excited to chat. So twenty five years in the game. that is that is nothing to shake a stick at. What what was your first kind of one or two gigs or projects, however you want to dis what got you into e com? How’d you end up here?
speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. It’s kind of fascinating in the markets today. We’re we’re comparing, you know, the AI boom to the 99-2000 internet bubble. So I come from that era. I actually graduated right when the e-commerce sort of bust internet bust happened, and there were no jobs to be found, and so My first sort of training wheels was really building a small business and helping merchants kind of get their online presence going, selling online. So e-commerce platforms are very close and dear to me. Small businesses are very dear to me. And yeah, those are all of my early learnings about how to build a business, what channels, what platforms matter. At the time it used to be that you know. businesses were skeptical about actually putting their stuff online and you know e-commerce payments were just taken off and marketplaces were just in their nascent stages. So we’ve come a long way since then and certainly lots of learnings. I’ve also had not only a bunch of years helping businesses get their presence online, but I’ve also got some experience working at Amazon. So I’ve kind of seen platform and selling at scale. So definitely Lots of learnings over the past couple of decades.
speaker-1: Absolutely. when we do this show, I you know, oftentimes it I like to highlight kind of just the the growth along the way of you know figuring out how to build a business, you know, you just have to make choices and you have to pivot and you have to kind of start to identify where there’s gaps in the market and where to double down. So I guess in the history of Web Gility, you know, from what it looks like now. to what the idea was it when you when you first launched, how different is it?
speaker-0: it’s fascinating. In some ways it’s completely different. In some ways it’s almost the same. when when I think about what’s identical, you know, if rewind back twenty years ago, merchants were still trying to figure out how to make sense of all of their e-commerce data. They were trying to figure out which channels to sell, where would they actually make money? but the problems were very basic then. It was really about how do I get my products online and how do I sell. fast forward a couple of decades, now it’s less about how do I sell, where do I sell? It’s actually how do I make money doing it. Right. And so certainly the problems kind of shifted, but at its very core, what was true then is still true now. You have to find new opportunities for growth. You have to sell in new channels and marketplaces. You now have multiple ways in which you can collect payments, multiple ways in which you can do fulfillment. You have to think about cross-border. You have to, of course, now think about sales tax. So as businesses have started selling more online, the complexity has only gotten greater and the margins have only become smaller, which makes the problem of finance and accounting as important, if not more so now. I think it’s one of those. unsexy things that people really need to pay attention to. And what I see most often is businesses that win and get to seven, eight figures are the ones that have figured out and mastered their data and their financials.
speaker-1: Absolutely. And you came in and you wanted to speak to this idea of why an e-commerce seller’s bank balance never matches what is in QuickBooks. So let’s kind of dive in a bit there. Now are y are is Web Jody a QuickBooks partner or competitor? How does that work out?
speaker-0: Yeah, we’re web we’re definitely a a QuickBooks partner over the years. We’ve been their preferred and strategic partners all the way from their early product of QuickBooks Point of Sale to QuickBooks Enterprise. And now we’re a gold certified partner with their QuickBooks online product suite, including the Internet Enterprise Suite. But you know, we also cover Zero and that suite. but QuickBooks has always been kind of a core platform we’ve supported. It’s w it’s if I go back again to my early days, why QuickBooks? Well, even fast forward twenty plus years, QuickBooks remains one of the only systems of record that most small businesses have that actually has like clean data.
speaker-1: It is arguably pretty easy to get set up and to get going. so they did a great job of lowering the barrier of entry for small businesses.
speaker-0: Absolutely. But as as complexity is rising, so are the tools. And now, you know, starting with something basic as a general ledger, now you start to tack on peril and sales tax and ARAP, like you start to add layers and layers of complexity and that makes it obviously more and more challenging and you have to really learn the system. But you know, we focus primarily on, you know, multi-channel brands and our kind of you know, my real emphasis over the last couple of years has been really how do we make life easy for these merchants, right? Because you don’t become a founder to become an accountant. you become a founder because you’re passionate about your business. You want to grow, you want to find products, you you want to engage with your customers and kind of build your brand. And ultimately most founders kind of look at accounting and finance as this compliance necessity and they think about it really late. And most often I don’t wanna say they wing it, but they kinda do, right? they’re really looking at their top level revenue data and their sales channel. They’re keeping a close eye on their bank balance periodically and doing some math in Excel to figure out, hey, what’s roughly my margin, what’s roughly my cash flow, where should I be spending a little bit more or less? And what we really find is that, you know, to certain scale, you can By looking at those things in a lump sum periodic way. But really, as you start to scale, especially if you’re going to build a high growth brand and expand it to multiple channels and geographies, you have to really dial down your numbers and that cash flow, the amount of money that’s tied up in your inventory, how much you’re paying in storage, how much racking up in all your marketplace and your other selling fees, ultimately all of that. expense line item, the bottom line is where, that makes or break, I think, success. too often I think people look at just the top line revenue from their sales channel and think that that’s a, you know, that’s where all the story is.
speaker-1: Yeah, it’s I agree with you. You can get away with it for a certain time. And I’d even argue I think like from zero to a million dollars a year for an e-commerce direct consumer business, probably focusing on one channel. Maybe you’ve got a backup. You’re probably focusing on one marketing avenue, maybe two. but at that point it is like this number’s bigger than this number. We are growing to a certain extent. And you you you don’t have enough money to hire experts or put the right products or tools in place, which is okay and that’s fine. And I think, it also there’s something to be said about not over engineering things at the start to where you do need to just go out there and sell it and make sure you have product market fit and make sure you have a viable business. Then as you get past, a million, you’re tracking towards you know, 10, becoming like a an eight figure business like everybody wants to be. then then it does become more around about you have to know your numbers, you have to know where your profitability is. especially like you said, once it gets more complex with different markets either and different channels, you know, the rates that Amazon are taking are is different than the rates from your own online store versus the rates that you’re getting from getting put onto your wholesale partner shelves. Also it is more expensive to sell in certain countries based upon other criteria, taxes, tariffs, et cetera. So all of these things you definitely need to have tools in place. And luckily, a lot of these are just rules that exist and it is pretty straightforward math, but it is unfortunately it is pretty unique to each individual product and company at the end of the day. So
speaker-0: Yeah, listen, I I’d love to believe that it’s straightforward. What we find that it’s not, right? That it’s also a moving target, right? You you think about the ever-changing landscape of marketplace fees. New fees are getting tacked on and new ways of selling are emerging. And you know, I’ll give you a simple example. Just what last month Amazon announced that you can pull in all of your non-Amazon orders. First, first time ever, Amazon’s opening up its market. place and seller central so you can pull in data from your Shopify, your TikTok, your Walmart stores. I’m not quite sure who wants to do that, but let’s just say you decide to. Now you’ve got Amazon actually capturing revenue data from other channels. And if that starts to appear in your settlement fees, boy, when you get that feed every couple of weeks Don’t be surprised. We’ve already talked to a few customers that have tried it and are seeing now duplicates show up because now they’re double counting their revenue. So, you know, just the way you handle your data, what you plug in, where you’re looking at kind of your chart of accounts and how money is flowing across the different channels, that level of complexity, especially for a multi-channel merchant. So I totally agree with what you’re saying about, you know, early stage. If you’re sub one million, you’re just getting started. At that point, really, it’s a game of do I have a viable business? And once you’re past that stage, that’s when you know start to think about growing your brand and expanding to multiple channels. And every channel you add creates another layer of complexity. Every new payment method you enable, every new sh fulfillment mechanism, new vendors you bring on. All of these aspects start to compound the complexity and that’s what we try to untangle and we’ve been working on this problem now for a while and the puck keeps to seem you know, keeps moving because we get some things right, but then the complexity kind of continues to increase. Absolutely.
speaker-1: Absolutely. I think that everybody talks about top line revenue. we’re an X million dollar business, et cetera. But I don’t care about that. And I I think you at being in this game long enough know that that number is very it it can be deceiving at the end of the day. So the real number we should be looking at is profit, right? and so most sellers think they know their profit. What do you think they’re usually like missing in that calculation? and in margin and how how far off are they usually? Yeah.
speaker-0: So I think the first place where things break is when sellers don’t do something as simple as looking at all of the deductions, the fees, the returns, their reserve accounts from their marketplaces. So just looking at the net deposit from your marketplaces, the number one place where early stage entrepreneurs go wrong, they think that that’s their revenue, which is a categorically wrong. Because your net deposit is just the net of fees, your top line revenue minus all of the expenses that were deducted is what you should be recording in your financial system to get a true sense of what your margins are. at the the second place where I see a lot of kind of confusion and and and misses Is not taking into account your channel level profitability. So you might be looking on aggregate at your overall business and have some sort of a quarterly close period, maybe, and looking lump sum at okay, total money in, what’s in my inventory asset, what was my cost and payroll and so forth. But the moment you start to unpack and actually look at it on a channel by channel basis, that’s when the second unlock happens because you realize. You’re maybe miscategorizing certain expenses to certain channels, and that would dramatically change what your profitability is by the channel. Similarly, I see that you since you’re helping a lot of merchants, I’m assuming also with advertising, that’s another place that things go awry is you know, start to look at your advertising expenses and aggregate, that’ll paint a very different picture versus putting your advertising expenses by channel to really figure out what’s happening. The third layer is then. Where the true unlock is is do you actually know your SKU level margins? And can you try to sort of attribute by skew by channel what you’re making money on? And by the time you get to that level of math, there’s definitely the level of sophistication that’s needed of how you organize your financials and your ac your books. But that’s when I think businesses that Dramatically scale and see that exponential growth because they can go in with confidence and start to put dollars to work. They understand what their unit economics are for every SKU. They understand what the payback period is on the advertising spend. So that they’re not shy of putting that money down because they know they’re going to get their returns. They also have a good handle of their chargeback rates. They’re understanding what the attribution is. for all of the different advertising channels as well for those SKUs. So they know what to dial up and what to dial down. So, you know, it could get complicated in a hurry, but you know, at various stages of the merchant’s journey, you have to sort of add a layer of sophistication to sort of understand the flow of money and where you’re truly making it in a in a profitable way so that you know which levers to dial up and dial down.
speaker-1: Hey everybody, just a quick reminder. Please like this video and subscribe if you haven’t. We’re releasing interviews like this every week. So don’t miss out. Now back to the interview. I feel that, you know, zero to one, you’re figuring it out. One to ten, you’re rebuilding the systems that got you to one million. but beyond that, it does become unfortunately, and this is what some founders like and some founders don’t like, it is. Truly just math at a certain point. And it’s how well can you invest money in the right things to return a profit? And that’s all it is at the end of the day. You could argue, well, you know, there’s all sorts of things to running a business. But once you find product market fit and you know that if you put advertising dollars or energy into this thing, it will produce profit. That’s what things kind of distill down into. Then it c becomes kind of a money shell game of. How quickly can I get this money back? How long can I go to not pay this money? Because any investment you make in inventory, it just sits on the shelf. It’s arguably money. Right. So then it just becomes this money shell game at a certain sense. And you gotta know those numbers to be able to make the right choices.
speaker-0: Hundred percent, hundred percent. And people often think about, SaaS as also like software subscription process. You kind of collect revenue, you have a pac payback period. But this is so different than what e-commerce is about because in e-commerce as well, you’re having like a turn of your inventory. And so, you know, your inventory is your asset and the faster you can sell it, now you’re also incurring a ton of storage-related fees, even if you were to say place your goods on Amazon. So the faster you turn your inventory, you can you know make a better margin. And especially when I think about you know the time that we are, we haven’t spoken about AI much, but you know, when I think about what is truly differentiating for merchants now, for them to scale, I mean you have to get velocity, right? And so how do you pick up speed if you’re not confident and comfortable in your data. I posted actually on LinkedIn once just a couple of months ago that every one degree that you’re off in your calculation, the faster you go, the farther away you are from your target. Right. And so you want to be pointing at the bullseye, you want to be constantly looking at where your what your cash flow looks like, what your channels and SKUs are profitable. And to really stand out, you want to double triple down on your winners and really cut your losers fast. I don’t like to think about it as a sh as a shell game, if you will, but I think it’s really financial engineering. You really
speaker-1: Yeah, that does sound scammy.
speaker-0: it’s it’s really all about, you know, do understand the mechanics of how you’re making money? And by the way, if you know, if if anyone’s thinking that this is tricky and complicated. I mean, the the fact of the matter, this is how you win. I mean, this is the proven playbook of Amazon. Amazon for decades had negative margins, made no money on practically so many of their businesses, so that they capture market share. And at some point now they just have to turn the dial. They capture the market. They figured out that they’ve got, you know, the customer base and the scale to now you start to really uncover Cork and start to get the profit engine moving. And I think right now, especially with AI, man, it’s so easy now to go look for a new product. It’s so easy to get, you know, products shipped in at low cost. You can generate so many ad campaigns. Let’s not talk about all the AI slop out there, but there’s definitely a lot of crazy, cool, interesting things people are doing to generate content and videos and social the influencer campaigns. But ultimately all of that power means you need to have the confidence to know how where you’re going to deploy your money. And how can you run a lot of rapid experiments? And so I think knowing your financials and understanding those unit economics is more essential now than it’s ever been because you need to place your bets and there’s a window of opportunity and all the categories are getting crowded. So you have to continue to really understand your numbers if you’re gonna find that path to growth.
speaker-1: Absolutely. obviously we can’t not have this conversation without talking about AI. And I know that that’s affected the service and the product over there. So how how have you and the team been adopting it? And how are your customers and clients seeing the benefits of AI? and obviously like how rapidly is it changing stuff?
speaker-0: Changing everything, So I like to think about of a of AI in in two ways. One is what’s it doing for our business? And number two, what’s it doing for our customers, right? So, how can we really leverage AI to improve the quality of our operations and serve our customers better? And what can we do with AI to really empower our customers and help them be more successful? And so internally, we’re, you know, incredibly AI pilled across all parts of our business. We’re very methodical about, you know, content and what we do with marketing because there’s definitely just tons of AI slop out there. But across the board, you know, our from our engineering to our customer support teams to our sales teams and product, we’re using AI prolifically to Build new capabilities into our software, develop optimizations, be able to respond and manage customer support stories, build new capabilities in the product at a lightning speed pace. in terms of our customers, you know, we see quite a bit of interesting diversion. You know, when you think about accounting and financial data, on the one hand, I love sort of how creative AI can can get and the power that it brings, but its accuracy is, across any benchmark on accounting and financial data, is still in the 80s or you know, low 90 percentage. And nobody wants their books to be 95% right. you want your books to be 100% right. you you can’t miss those numbers. And so what we like to think about and do with AI is we empower our teams to leverage AI to do analysis and help build better product. But what we launched this past summer is actually what I would call our response to how someone should deal with AI i in today’s world is actually to build more human accountability. So we’ve got a team of accountants that we’ve been adding to WebGility that provide the human element where we not only give you our core platform where you can certainly Manage your financials, look at your real-time stats across all your channels and close your books. But we now provide an accountant, which gives you the confidence that along with the software, you get the human expertise and the accountability that your data is not 90, 95% right. It’s 100% right. And so we have added a a layer of human accountability to our service. In response to what we believe is actually just a lot of noise and complexity. Everyone’s selling some sort of an agentic solution. But you know, businesses don’t just need agents, they need accountability. They need someone that guarantees that what they’re seeing in their books is accurate. So we back what we provide our core platform with now a human layer. And behind the scenes, obviously our team is doing a lot of agentic capabilities and we have our own A AI closing agents internally, but we’re continuing to streamline all of that and shield a customer from that complexity, but give them the confidence that you know, we they can rely on us to manage and close their books.
speaker-1: Absolutely. Now, if I’m listening to this episode and I’m curious to learn more about Web Agility and see if, you know, we might be a good fit to work together, where should I go? What should I do? Yeah.
speaker-0: It’s pretty easy. Just go to WebGility.com and we actually have an e-commerce after dark clinic that I’m excited about that’s coming up here shortly. I don’t it is probably gonna be before this podcast is published, but we’d love for you to check out the recording. we also have you know I publish routinely on on LinkedIn, so you can follow me, Parag Mamnani, for e-commerce related small business and AI. I’m really a big fan of all of these things and I’m I’m a big advocate for S and B, so I spent a lot of my time thinking about what we can do to help these small businesses win.
speaker-1: Awesome, Parag, thank you so much for coming on the show today and sharing all those amazing insights.
speaker-0: Awesome. Thanks so much for having me, Chase.